≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

Cheapest locales for excellent homeopathy?

I am considering travel to a place where homeopaths both (a) are more common, and (b) charge lower fees, than where I now live. I am considering this because I am jobless, have enough frequent-flyer miles for free airfare, and will have to pay for my care by early withdrawal from my small retirement fund. Therefore, which countries, locales, and homeopaths should I consider? India, and some well-known homeopaths such as Sankaran, occur to me. Could I expect to pay fees closer to what locals pay, to some homeopaths in India or elsewhere?
 
  madscientist37 on 2009-12-03
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
I neglected to mention that I intend to remain in the selected local for at least 3 months, or, if I can get the necessary visa, a year or more. Long-term follow-up may be required, and airfare is expensive. Still, given that my funds may last longer outside the U.S., I consider an extended time abroad more cost-effective than seeing a U.S. homeopath.
 
madscientist37 last decade
In Calcutta everybody is homeopath and service is free or rather you may find people who will serve you tea as well supper also if you listen to their advise. And many will give you medicine too free, if you listen to them.

So if you want to listen ... both sides get treatment.
 
girilal last decade
girilal, I appreciate your humor. People do love to give advice, even (especially?) if they are not experts. (And perhaps some of that happens on some web-based homeopathy forums.) But chiefly, I hope to take advantage of differences in cost-of-living. Probably (not necessarily) the /best/ homeopaths in, say, India, can charge lower fees than the best homeopaths in the USA; but mainly, during my convalescence it would cost me less to live in, say, India, than in the USA.

I do have money; I simply want to spend it where local costs are low. For example, I recently spent a month in a village in the Peruvian Amazon region; there I met people with whom I could have negotiated room and board for $100 per month. Such things are feasible for me since I am an experienced traveler since early childhood.

Essentially, here I am asking two things:

1. Other than India, which countries (if any) are worth considering?

2. Which good homeopaths practice in regions with lowest cost of living?
 
madscientist37 last decade
One free advise I too will like to give you.

A famous or more expansive homeopathy or just any physician may not necessarily be the best one or just skilled one. Getting famous is entirely a different skill, it has nothing to do with homeopathy.

So just beware of the expansive or famous people.

Best is to put your problem here on this forum, and in the process you too will become a homeopathy or rather learn a great deal about your own ailment so it all fails here then you can present your case with better skill to the would be homeopath who will eventually cure you.
 
girilal last decade
madscientist37

India, and some well-known homeopaths such as Sankaran, occur to me. Could I expect to pay fees closer to what locals pay, to some homeopaths in India or elsewhere?
Anywhere in the world people tempt to charge dollar revenue if they see that the person seeking service is not a local. So it is better to get the assurance from the concerned homeopath about his charges. Doing this is easy now as many homeopaths have their websites.

girilal

In Calcutta everybody is homeopath and service is free or rather you may find people who will serve you tea as well supper also if you listen to their advise. And many will give you medicine too free, if you listen to them.

So if you want to listen ... both sides get treatment.

It depends. Anybody will love to entertain a person with great sense of humour. Similarly they would love to thrash a person with outrageous manners. So giri whatever personal experience you have cannot be generalized.
 
kadwa last decade
Girilal breaks silence after a long hiatus. Welcome back!
 
srisri last decade
Quest was: Cheapest locales for excellent homeopathy?

So I suggested Calcutta, not just cheapest but also one can get free suppers as well teas.
 
girilal last decade
People thought that they can only recieve free advice on homeopathic medication. But now they also know they can also get free supper and tea!!! Thatswhy experts(?) say that that homeo remedies not only act at dynamic plane but they also provide nutrition.
 
kadwa last decade
Thank you all for your replies. I am pleased to see that I have found quite a humorous group of people! I will work on writing out my list of symptoms. Although I have been intimidated by this task (I have enough symptoms that no one remedy, or set of several remedies, seems to cover them all), I suspect that this, as self-reflection, as a form of meditation, may be a form of homeopathy itself.? Once I post that, I will look forward to thought-provoking responses, and, I trust, humorous ones too. :)
 
madscientist37 last decade
You will nail your problem if you begin with your mental symptoms.
 
girilal last decade
madscientist37

This name gives some insight about where to start the treatment.
 
girilal last decade
Indeed. :)
 
madscientist37 last decade
How much should I write? To jog my own memory, I have written a narrative, the form I generally prefer. But some consider me to be long-winded. :)

Alternately, I could use the Remedy Finder and list the names of my mental symptoms; but so many of the symptoms -- even the mental ones -- seem to apply, that I would again generate a long list.

I suspect that various responders will each have their own preferences, and that if I take one approach I'll get responses from those who prefer that approach. I'd prefer the narrative, but if everyone is against it, I'll do the other.
 
madscientist37 last decade
I suspect that various responders will each have their own preferences, and that if I take one approach I'll get responses from those who prefer that approach. I'd prefer the narrative, but if everyone is against it, I'll do the other.
Don't involve many responders at a time. You write down a long narrative here and Giri will respond.
 
kadwa last decade
i am still working on the narrative. the poor state of my mind limits insight into myself and/or my trust thereof, and in addition, what i write seems awfully narcissistic and confused. i will ask some friends and relatives to help me summarize my mental symptoms. meanwhile here is a symptom grid. i would be very grateful for any insight or further direction that girilal (mr. lal?) can give me.

 
madscientist37 last decade
A few more notes; I'll try to be concise:

To evaluate my cognition I have been playing brain-training games designed by neurologists. On short-term (active) memory I score in the 12th percentile.

In perspective, in when I took a standard Weschler IQ test in 2004 I scored 146 (99.9th percentile). In 2007 my score dropped about 20 points. By now it seems much worse. Depression may damage the brain.

I have been diagnosed with depression. I have some anxiety, some lack of motivation, most worst is my ahedonia (experiencing too little pleasure from experiences expected to be pleasurable).

My other diagnoses include bipolar disorder (2007) and chronic fatigue syndrome (2008, but I think I've had it since 1992).

I have a girlfriend whom I have known for 3.5 years. We have broken up 3 times and most recently were separated for 16 months. We reuinited, as each time before, impulsively, without adequate deliberation. I do love her -- want the best for her and am motivate to attempt many compromises to benefit her and her family -- and doubt I could find another woman as sweet or as faithful. But my passion for her is too weak to motivate me to marry her. I don't know whether this is my intuition or animal self telling me she's not 'the one,' or whether this is simply my ahedonia.

I feel alternately homesick and apathetic toward my family. Both divorced parents, and my siblings, live far away from where I live, which is in our ancestral region.

I have mood swings. My moods change quickly and unexpectedly.

I tend not to have any evidence of dreams; it's possible that I don't dream at all, except for 3-4 dreams per year. This has been the case since I was 11 or 12. (Incidentally that was the same year my father stopped dreaming.)

I am compulsively, often 'brutally,' honest. This may be a reason that my subconscious keeps some secrets from me: if I were to know them, I would blurt them out to one and all.

More and more, I experience something like 'moral fatigue' or 'demoralization.' I was always overly conscientious, and now I am often nearly tired of being conscientious. My anxious disposition kept me from following my passion in youth; I became an engineer though I had begun to loathe such work by my second year of university. I have been too depressed to learn a new trade, and now at 36 I want to become a hippie -- if only this would probably require me to abandon responsibilities to my girlfriend and family.

I am hypersensitive to stimuli, especially auditory and visual. Food and touch seem to soothe me. I have this in common with some autistics. But unlike them I am not literal-minded; I am fairly poetic. (I like homeopathy for the fact that excellent practioners must think metaphorically.)

I do have trouble remembering peoples' faces and names.

I don't sleep well, perhaps mostly because I wake many times to urinate. This is not just small bits of urine here and here; rather, my urine is copious, yellow or brownish-yellow, and frothy. I wake unrefreshed. If I urinate in a jug at night, it contains 2 liters in the morning. Each time I urinate it is about 0.75L.

My girlfriend adds that I judge myself 'harshly and belatedly.'

I may write more later as I think of it.
 
madscientist37 last decade
Oops. A correction: Where I wrote:
'I want to become a hippie -- if only this would probably require...'
please read
'I want to become a hippie -- EXCEPT that this would probably require.'
 
madscientist37 last decade
Perhaps it is relevant that:

1. Often I have been drawn to contentious and argumentative, close-knit groups of people, with whom, after some years, I eventually grow disgusted. Examples: evangelical Christian intellectuals; 'deep ecology' environmentalists

2. I was very shy around women; I was a virgin until age 33. My present girlfriend is the first woman with whom I had sex.

I regret my lack of organization; please forgive me.
 
madscientist37 last decade
Can you sit, just sit or you must do something or must keep yourself busy?
 
girilal last decade
If I understand you properly, no. It is difficult for me to sit to meditate. I can sit still for quite long periods of time -- until I have to urinate -- only if I am reading or listening to music.
 
madscientist37 last decade
BTW, one complication is that, for the last few years, I have been addicted to chocolate. Most of the rubriks in Sherr's proving do apply to my case. I have just posted, under separate cover, a question about how to prepare a remedy from chocolate:

http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/208196/

I also have similar questions about some more of my addictions, including wheat and dairy products. Both contain proteins (peptides homologous to opioids) that are soluble neither in water, nor in alcohol, nor in oil. But perhaps the initial succussion suffices to copy their energy in a medium of water?

I acknowledge that by asking such questions I implicitly touch on discussions about distinctions between classical or 'true' homeopathy and systems like homotoxicology. While I am familiar with the debate I have no desire to resurrect it here. ( I am only an intellectual/bookish patient who has been treated, without success, by numerous allopathic and a few homeopathic physicians.)
 
madscientist37 last decade
Mr. Lal, I don't mean to rush you, but while you are pondering, if you prefer that I also post a chronological narrative -- perhaps in order to unwrap my case like an onion's layers -- I would be happy to post one. In that event, would you please post a link to one or more examples of patient's narratives that you consider to be well-written?
 
madscientist37 last decade
An anecdote from my attempt at isopathy (or is it tautopathy?) may at least amuse you:
http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/208206/
 
madscientist37 last decade
 
srisri last decade
Thank you, srisri. The Remedy Finder makes quite a case for Sulfer and I would be surprised if girilal did not also recommend Sulfur. I am eager to see his response, particular with regard to posology. Also, if I need any complementary remedies, for the symptoms not covered by Sulfur, are they effectual after Sulfur or must they be taken prior to it.

In fact, I bought Boiron's Sulf 30C from my local health food store two years ago, based on the Remedy Finder. I bought 30C because it was the only potency available there. On 15 Feb 2008 I took 5 pellets at 8:15am, and again at 5:30pm, but it did not produce any changes that I deemed noteworthy at the time. (In hindsight, I suspect it may have led to an aggravation that precipitated the most recent, 16-month separation from my girlfriend.) Perhaps another potency and/or dosing schedule would work better for me.

I might regarded as 'highly sensitive' to things like foods (I experience mental symptoms after wheat, dairy, soy, egg, peanut), but also as having a weak vital force. (I suspect my chi has been low ever since I was 19 and masturbated too much!) So, with regard to homeopathics, I do not know whether I am relatively sensitive or relatively insensitive.

In the past, I have been responsive to Boiron's Sepia 6C and Oscillococcinum 200C -- each taken as per manufacturer's recommended dosing schedule. The former, which I took in attempt to control mood swings, alleviated genital itching, and the latter, which I took to quell a flu, calmed my mind.

Sometime in 2002, I was prescribed Pulsatilla (potency not marked), and this may have played a role in my transition from an overly conscientious person to a Sulfur. (That year I quit my engineering job and began five years of self-funded medical 'research.') Circa April 2007, I was prescribed Nitricum Acidum 1M as a constitutional and was told to take a few grains once; this seemed not to produce a response.

Given my history of extensive allopathic treatment -- from age 11 months until circa 32 years old -- I would not be surprised if I need a series of antidotes to past allopathic treatments. In particular, I was heavily exposed to stannous fluoride via a gel that was prescribed for home use, and now I have numerous symptoms of fluoride remedies. Also, I had adverse reactions to at least two vaccines containing aluminum and organic mercury. In case I also need remedies for those, I would like to know in advance, whether they can be given after my constitutional remedy, be that Sulfur or another.
 
madscientist37 last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.