The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Can homoepathetic help me?
I've been seeing a homomeopath for almost two years and I don't feel much better expect that I haven't taken antibiotics or other medicine for two years .I'am a woman 46 years old and I have been diagnosed bronnchiectasis since I was 12 years old.The last three years my problem is more acute.I cough and spit very often during the day and once a month have bloody spits for 1-3 days.I also have a running nose especially during the winter or when I stoop.Please answer me: a) is homoepathetic going to cure my problems or make me feel better and how long should I still wait?b) which remedy could be best for my case? Now I take calcarea ph c)should i consult another homoepath doctor who is more specialized in lung diseases?
Thank you for your answer
afroditi on 2003-07-24
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
(This message is posted here by way of an exchange of views and does not constitute a medical prescription).
Following medicines likely to help you. (See also Materia Medica).
1. MERCURIUS SOL. 30C and
2. PHOSPHORUS 30C.....each three times a day in alteration.
Please get a chest X-ray done and show your self to a doctor if it has an adverse report.
Best,
PANKAJ VARMA
pvarma7
yahoo.com
Following medicines likely to help you. (See also Materia Medica).
1. MERCURIUS SOL. 30C and
2. PHOSPHORUS 30C.....each three times a day in alteration.
Please get a chest X-ray done and show your self to a doctor if it has an adverse report.
Best,
PANKAJ VARMA
pvarma7
yahoo.com
♡ PANKAJ VARMA 2 decades ago
Dear Ma'am,
Homeopathy is most accurate when there are lots of big, obvious, dramatic symptoms.
In the case of Bronchitis, you qualify. The correct remedy should be obvious, and should show improvement within a couple of days. A couple of years just doesn't sound right.
Yes, go to an MD, get the x-ray and other tests he might want to run. Western White Man's science is excellent for diagnosis, so take advantage (if you can afford it). You have to make sure that there are no other sickness making trouble that we're not aware of.
After all that, if it's just chronic Bronchitis, thank the doctor, take his antibiotic prescription-form, put it in your file cabinet, and go see another homeopath.
You mentioned the option of seeing another homeopath who is more experienced with lung diseases. I hope you can do that; most of us are lucky to have one homeopath within 500 miles.
Not that I know how to select remedies myself, but still, with all your symptoms, this shouldn't be difficult.
If it turns out you have something more than Bronchitis, it doesn't really matter, because Homeopathy doesn't care what's the cause, but only your symptoms. But the extra information from the medical tests might be useful to add to your list of symptoms.
Also, are you antidoting remedies? Are you staying away from coffee, mint, and moth balls? You're not putting moth balls in you coffee, are you?
Stop laughing; it will only make you cough.
You'll be fine.
Best luck,
-Neil-
Homeopathy is most accurate when there are lots of big, obvious, dramatic symptoms.
In the case of Bronchitis, you qualify. The correct remedy should be obvious, and should show improvement within a couple of days. A couple of years just doesn't sound right.
Yes, go to an MD, get the x-ray and other tests he might want to run. Western White Man's science is excellent for diagnosis, so take advantage (if you can afford it). You have to make sure that there are no other sickness making trouble that we're not aware of.
After all that, if it's just chronic Bronchitis, thank the doctor, take his antibiotic prescription-form, put it in your file cabinet, and go see another homeopath.
You mentioned the option of seeing another homeopath who is more experienced with lung diseases. I hope you can do that; most of us are lucky to have one homeopath within 500 miles.
Not that I know how to select remedies myself, but still, with all your symptoms, this shouldn't be difficult.
If it turns out you have something more than Bronchitis, it doesn't really matter, because Homeopathy doesn't care what's the cause, but only your symptoms. But the extra information from the medical tests might be useful to add to your list of symptoms.
Also, are you antidoting remedies? Are you staying away from coffee, mint, and moth balls? You're not putting moth balls in you coffee, are you?
Stop laughing; it will only make you cough.
You'll be fine.
Best luck,
-Neil-
neiljn 2 decades ago
Yeh, one thing my Homeopath once said is that homeopaths who are not medical school graduates might not recognize a dangerous condition that requires first aid NOW. He gave, for example, the case of a homeopath that was trying - unsuccessfully - to treat mononucleosis, but the patient had AIDS. So if your homeopath is "only" a practitioner, you might save your life by first going to an MD (or D.O.), and eliminating worser sickness from consideration. Anyway, as a professional electronics engineer, it sounds to me like you have a bacterial infection. Drink a quart of water every two hours until this problem is licked. Dehydration aggravates everything. Pop 500 mG of Ester-C (non-acidic form of vitamin C, and very easy on the stomach) 6 times per day. Don't take food within 1/2 hour of taking a remedy.
neiljn 2 decades ago
Hello, I'm back.
.....................
I've been reading about Bronchiectasis, and I see it's not bronchitis.
.....................
Sorry I assumed that you were making a spelling error. I preferred to see what I wanted to see.
.....................
http://www.lung.ca/diseases/bronchiectasis.html
.....................
The article says that there is damage to the lung(s), possibly from an obstruction in the bronchi, or loss of cilia that would otherwise be pushing dust, germs, and mucus out of the lungs.
.....................
The infections are a secondary effect, but the way they present themselves - the blood and other assorted colors you spit, the complete description of the pain (I know you got it), other discomforts around your body, and the modalities (what makes you feel worse, what makes you feel better), all point to a remedy that will help to get you on top of these infections.
.....................
After two years, I'm sure you've learned that the homeopath requires complete descriptions of every little thing, in contrast to regular doctors that want only as much information as they require to label your illness.
.....................
It goes against the culture, where we are taught to keep as much of our pain to ourselves, as much as possible. In contrast, you should be sharing everything with your homeopath enthusiastically, to ensure the proper selection of the remedy. A good homeopath will let you vent yourself to exhaustion.
.....................
According to the article (I read an article and now I'm dangerous...), if the obstruction in the lung is still present, they can remove that section, surgically. That would eliminate the source of the obstruction, and the secondary infections will stop.
.....................
They will probably want to do pre- and post-surgical antibiotics. Given the cleanliness of hospitals, it might not be a bad idea. Remember to follow antibiotic treatment with acidophilus for a couple of weeks, to replenish your beneficial, intestinal flora.
.....................
Personally, I believe that the healing powers of the body are highly underestimated, and ejecting long-stuck foreign objects from the lungs and regenerating long-lost cilia are quite possible with the right remedy.
.....................
Dr. Hahnemann, the father of homeopathy, would disagree with me. He would say that there is a certain point at which the tissues are so far gone, that homeopathy cannot be expected to return health to them.
.....................
Probably, the truth is somewhere in between. There is probably a small area of the lung that cannot come back, but you - and a lot of doctors - may be surprised at how much of your lungs will come back, leaving you with more function than you thought possible.
.....................
In the meantime, if x-rays show there is blockage from a foreign object, perhaps you might consider having it removed surgically, because there is still the continuing problem of the blocked bronchi continuing to generate infection, doing more damage, and continuing to spread infection and damage to more areas of the lung, and maybe beyond. Unless you have exceptional homeopathic support today, you might see about determining if you have an obvious obstruction that can be removed, ASAP.
.....................
The article also mentions that bronchiectases can be caused by an "inherited primary abnormality of the cilia" i.e., Bad Genes. In this case, there is no foreign blockage, and I don't know if surgery would have any value with this. But homeopathy should improve whatever functioning can possibly be salvaged, and put a significant dent in all of those infections. (It seems to me that you should be having more success, today, against those infections, whatever the cause.) Continued "constitutional homeopathic treatment" would continue to decrease the rate of infections, and after a couple of years, the trouble should be all in the past.
.....................
I'm the last person to suggest antibiotics, but unless your homeopath can significantly reduce that infection, you might consider taking drugs to limit further damage. You can always stop taking them again, when you find a better homeopath. Doesn't he recognize that the blood indicates that lung tissue is being lost, today?
.....................
Well, if your homeopath doesn't realize s/he is fighting a losing battle against a foreign obstruction, that is one thing. But if you can have the foreign obstruction removed, your present homeopath probably has the competence to provide you a very fast recovery after surgery.
.....................
Surgery causes zinc depletion, so start taking that, besides the remedy, a few weeks before hand, until you're recovered. 50 mG per day is OK for a couple of weeks before and after surgery; 15 mG per day is maximum for maintenance.
.....................
You might want to look into some gentle methods of detoxifying your body, especially with the infection releasing byproducts, not to mention the antibiotics. (I know it's been a couple of years since you took them, but some chemicals can linger.) Too aggressive a detox will release toxins too quickly from your body into your blood, and you're not strong enough for that, yet. But there are some fiber products in the health food store that will give you two or three healthy BM's per day, and that is especially important for you, and may be all that you should do along those lines. Flatulence for the first week or two will subside thereafter. The cheapest formula is to get a pound of Whole Psyllium Seed, and take 1/8 teaspoon per day, followed by slowly drinking one of your bi-hourly quarts of water. Psyllium absorbs water to form bulk, and youll get an intestinal blockage if you dont take it with enough water. The water intake is still a valid point - not only for dehydration but also for elimination - even though I was on the wrong track in my last posting. A little better intestinal cleanliness will give your immune system one less thing to work on, leaving more energy available for fighting the lung infection.
.....................
Sorry if I write too much. Thanks for tolerating.
.....................
Hugs,
-Neil-
.....................
I've been reading about Bronchiectasis, and I see it's not bronchitis.
.....................
Sorry I assumed that you were making a spelling error. I preferred to see what I wanted to see.
.....................
http://www.lung.ca/diseases/bronchiectasis.html
.....................
The article says that there is damage to the lung(s), possibly from an obstruction in the bronchi, or loss of cilia that would otherwise be pushing dust, germs, and mucus out of the lungs.
.....................
The infections are a secondary effect, but the way they present themselves - the blood and other assorted colors you spit, the complete description of the pain (I know you got it), other discomforts around your body, and the modalities (what makes you feel worse, what makes you feel better), all point to a remedy that will help to get you on top of these infections.
.....................
After two years, I'm sure you've learned that the homeopath requires complete descriptions of every little thing, in contrast to regular doctors that want only as much information as they require to label your illness.
.....................
It goes against the culture, where we are taught to keep as much of our pain to ourselves, as much as possible. In contrast, you should be sharing everything with your homeopath enthusiastically, to ensure the proper selection of the remedy. A good homeopath will let you vent yourself to exhaustion.
.....................
According to the article (I read an article and now I'm dangerous...), if the obstruction in the lung is still present, they can remove that section, surgically. That would eliminate the source of the obstruction, and the secondary infections will stop.
.....................
They will probably want to do pre- and post-surgical antibiotics. Given the cleanliness of hospitals, it might not be a bad idea. Remember to follow antibiotic treatment with acidophilus for a couple of weeks, to replenish your beneficial, intestinal flora.
.....................
Personally, I believe that the healing powers of the body are highly underestimated, and ejecting long-stuck foreign objects from the lungs and regenerating long-lost cilia are quite possible with the right remedy.
.....................
Dr. Hahnemann, the father of homeopathy, would disagree with me. He would say that there is a certain point at which the tissues are so far gone, that homeopathy cannot be expected to return health to them.
.....................
Probably, the truth is somewhere in between. There is probably a small area of the lung that cannot come back, but you - and a lot of doctors - may be surprised at how much of your lungs will come back, leaving you with more function than you thought possible.
.....................
In the meantime, if x-rays show there is blockage from a foreign object, perhaps you might consider having it removed surgically, because there is still the continuing problem of the blocked bronchi continuing to generate infection, doing more damage, and continuing to spread infection and damage to more areas of the lung, and maybe beyond. Unless you have exceptional homeopathic support today, you might see about determining if you have an obvious obstruction that can be removed, ASAP.
.....................
The article also mentions that bronchiectases can be caused by an "inherited primary abnormality of the cilia" i.e., Bad Genes. In this case, there is no foreign blockage, and I don't know if surgery would have any value with this. But homeopathy should improve whatever functioning can possibly be salvaged, and put a significant dent in all of those infections. (It seems to me that you should be having more success, today, against those infections, whatever the cause.) Continued "constitutional homeopathic treatment" would continue to decrease the rate of infections, and after a couple of years, the trouble should be all in the past.
.....................
I'm the last person to suggest antibiotics, but unless your homeopath can significantly reduce that infection, you might consider taking drugs to limit further damage. You can always stop taking them again, when you find a better homeopath. Doesn't he recognize that the blood indicates that lung tissue is being lost, today?
.....................
Well, if your homeopath doesn't realize s/he is fighting a losing battle against a foreign obstruction, that is one thing. But if you can have the foreign obstruction removed, your present homeopath probably has the competence to provide you a very fast recovery after surgery.
.....................
Surgery causes zinc depletion, so start taking that, besides the remedy, a few weeks before hand, until you're recovered. 50 mG per day is OK for a couple of weeks before and after surgery; 15 mG per day is maximum for maintenance.
.....................
You might want to look into some gentle methods of detoxifying your body, especially with the infection releasing byproducts, not to mention the antibiotics. (I know it's been a couple of years since you took them, but some chemicals can linger.) Too aggressive a detox will release toxins too quickly from your body into your blood, and you're not strong enough for that, yet. But there are some fiber products in the health food store that will give you two or three healthy BM's per day, and that is especially important for you, and may be all that you should do along those lines. Flatulence for the first week or two will subside thereafter. The cheapest formula is to get a pound of Whole Psyllium Seed, and take 1/8 teaspoon per day, followed by slowly drinking one of your bi-hourly quarts of water. Psyllium absorbs water to form bulk, and youll get an intestinal blockage if you dont take it with enough water. The water intake is still a valid point - not only for dehydration but also for elimination - even though I was on the wrong track in my last posting. A little better intestinal cleanliness will give your immune system one less thing to work on, leaving more energy available for fighting the lung infection.
.....................
Sorry if I write too much. Thanks for tolerating.
.....................
Hugs,
-Neil-
neiljn 2 decades ago
I don't want to comment on your homeopath as I don't have complete details of your two year record with her/him.
I still repeat as a friendly suggestion:
QUOTE
Following medicines likely to help you. (See also Materia Medica).
1. MERCURIUS SOL. 30C and
2. PHOSPHORUS 30C.....each three times a day in alteration.
Please get a chest X-ray done and show your self to a doctor if it has an adverse report.
UNQUOTE
The above homeopathic medicines are based on pointed symptoms detailed by you and have been suggested in low potency of 30C.... not likely to harm you.
Side by side you can get the X-ray done for an additional diagnosis to eliminate the possibility of surprises.
We respect the allopaths for their diagnostic skills.
Best,
PANKAJ VARMA
pvarma7
yahoo.com
I still repeat as a friendly suggestion:
QUOTE
Following medicines likely to help you. (See also Materia Medica).
1. MERCURIUS SOL. 30C and
2. PHOSPHORUS 30C.....each three times a day in alteration.
Please get a chest X-ray done and show your self to a doctor if it has an adverse report.
UNQUOTE
The above homeopathic medicines are based on pointed symptoms detailed by you and have been suggested in low potency of 30C.... not likely to harm you.
Side by side you can get the X-ray done for an additional diagnosis to eliminate the possibility of surprises.
We respect the allopaths for their diagnostic skills.
Best,
PANKAJ VARMA
pvarma7
yahoo.com
♡ PANKAJ VARMA 2 decades ago
Go to your vitamin store or order on line Beta Glucan 1/3,1/6(made from the walls of bakers yeast). It kills bacterial,viral,and fungal infections. Take it everyday-it cured my lichen sclerosis.
Beta Glucan promotes healthy skin and tissue growth-even helps get rid of wrinkles.Basically it jumpstarts your immune system.It can also cure herpes,arthiritis,allergies,cancer,HIV,skin problems and more. I've also heard about Moducare-but I haven't tried that one,but beta glucan worked for me!
Beta Glucan promotes healthy skin and tissue growth-even helps get rid of wrinkles.Basically it jumpstarts your immune system.It can also cure herpes,arthiritis,allergies,cancer,HIV,skin problems and more. I've also heard about Moducare-but I haven't tried that one,but beta glucan worked for me!
Roxy90 last decade
Im a qualified microbiologist and work in the field of medical research. I have also had severe bronchiectasis for over 20 years but have it well under control at the moment. If you have bronchiectasis with recurrent lung infections you SHOULD be on prophylactic antibiotic therapy. Remember every infection you get causes damage to your lungs! This will make your condition worse. There is currently NO cure for the condition- do not believe what some uneducated/misinformed albeit wellmeaning people have posted. The best way to treat your condition is antibiotic therapy, exercise, physiotherapy to clear mucus from your lungs, staying hydrated, avoiding alcohol and coffee, eating a well balanced diet, reducing red meat consumption, taking vitamin C supplement (no more than 1000mg/day- long term megadosing of vit.C has been proven to increase the risk of cancer significantly), echinacea supplementation has been proven to reduce the frequency and severity of coughs and colds. It may not be popular to say this on this website but there is currently no scientific evidence proving any benefit from homeopathy! There may be plenty anecdotal evidence to suggest that it works, this can practically always be explained by the placebo effect- An apparently beneficial result of therapy that occurs because of the patients expectation that the therapy will help. A novel therapy which may benefit you is called Buteyko, which involves using breathing exercises to reduce overbreathing- there has been clinical trials carried out to substantiate some of its claims- but it is controvertial. I hope this is of some benefit.
the mad scientist last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.