The ABC Homeopathy Forum
No cure in sight :-(
I am undergoing classical homeopathic treatment for the last 10+ years.My main problems are feeling of anxiety, inability to perform mental work due to lack of confidence/concentration and confusion, anti-social nature, pain in knees, aching in lower back, gastric problems, gum problems, digestive problems, pais in chest, pains in bones and joints etc.My physician is a very good classical homeopath and always prescribes the correct simillimum.I feel improvements for a few hours only, then the symptom picture changes and I begin to feel terrible uneasiness.I again note down the smptoms and a new remedy is prescribed.Thus it has continued for over 10 years.My feeling is that since I am having multiple miasms, upon the correct action of a remedy, a new miasm is un-covered and it becomes dominant.
My question is why these miasms never seem to stop coming again and again.There have been countless cycles, in which the miasm surfaces again and again repeatedly even after having taken the correct simillimum.I have also taken nosodes like tub,pso,med,bowel nosodes etc for several times.
Pls see below the sample of my remdies for the last three months.Let me know if any of the esteemed members of this forum have any ideas on how I can proceed.
1.I want to know whether some remedy can be taken which meets the picture of all the below remedies (some bowel nosode or others)
2.How I can continue the treatment so that the miasms don`t appear again and again.
3.Any other remedy or ideas.
Thanks in advance
11,12,13,oct 2010 - sul 1m, nux 30
13 oct 2010 - merc sol 1m
16 oct 2010 - arg nit 1m
17 oct 2010 - thuja 1m
18 oct 2010 - graphites 30
19 oct 2010 - merc sol 1m
22 oct 2010 - arg nit 1m
24 oct 2010 - merc sol 1m
27 oct 2010 - staphysagria 1m
30 oct 2010 - SUL 1M,Arg Nit 1m
31 oct 2010 - merc sol 1m
02 nov 2010 - syph 1m
04 nov 2010 - merc sol 10m
08 & 09 nov 2010 - Graphites 30
10 nov 2010 - arg nit 1m
11 nov 2010 - sulphur 1m
12 & 13 nov 2010 - Graphites 30
13 nov 2010 - lycopodium 30
16 nov 2010 - lycopodium 1m
19 nov 2010 - calc ars 30
21 nov 2010 - nat mur 1m
24,25,26 nov 2010 - sul 1m / arg nit 1m
26 nov 2010 - graph 30
30 nov 2010 - thuja 1m
01 dec 2010 - nat mur 30 (3 dz)
04 dec 2010 - nitric acid 1m
07 dec 2010 - thuja 1m
08/9/10 dec 2010 - acid flu 200,ars alb 0/3
10 dec 2010 - ignatia 1m
12 dec 2010 - natrum mur 1m
13,14 dec 2010 ~ merc sol 30, 15 dec - merc 1m
16 dec 2010 - carbo veg 1m
18 dec 2010 - thuja 1m
19/20 dec 2010 ~ graph 30
21 dec 2010 - sul 1m
24 dec 2010 - nux vom 1m (2dz)
25 dec 2010 - sul 1m
26 dec 2010 - bacillinum 1m
28 dec 2010 - sul 1m, nux 30
29/30/31 - nux 30
31 dec 2010 - rhus tox 1m
02 jan 2011 - Merc sol 1m
03 jan 2011 - sul 1m
04 jan 2011 - ars alb 30
05 jan 2011 - sul 1m / ars alb 1m
06 jan 2011 - graph 1m
09/10 jan 2011 - merc sol 30 (3 dz )
11/jan/2011 - natrum mur 1m
12/jan/2011 - arnica 1m
14/jan/2011 - rhus tox 1m
15/jan/11 - graph 30
16/jan/11 - sul 1m/graph 30
khanf on 2011-01-16
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
This is very wrong. This person has given you different remedies only a few days after each other. This is very wrong. I would find a different practitioner immediately.
Or add your case to this forum. One correct remedy should last for weeks or months leading to constant improvement. Often you cannot see the full effects of a remedy for days or weeks after giving it.
Please find correct homeopathic treatment.
Or add your case to this forum. One correct remedy should last for weeks or months leading to constant improvement. Often you cannot see the full effects of a remedy for days or weeks after giving it.
Please find correct homeopathic treatment.
♡ Homeopathy International 1 last decade
Please fill out the homeopathic intake form for new patients. The more information you can give us, the more accurate our homeopathic recommendations can be. Hopefully someone here will help you begin real homeopathic treatment to resolve your issues.
http://abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/255920/
http://abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/255920/
♡ Homeopathy International 1 last decade
If what you say is correct, then it is the worse misuse of homeopathic treatment that I've ever seen.
♡ Homeopathy International 1 last decade
Dear Homeopathy International 1,
I was expecting such a reply from the forum.When I started the treatment around 10 years ago, the remedies used to act for more than a week and would produce aggravations (mental and physical).But, with the sustained treatment over several years, I have reached a point where the specific selected remedy for the presenting miasm would complete its work in a few hours and I will feel better, but within the next couple of hours, the other miasm would present itself and it would need to be treated similarly.
My concern is why the miasms seem to be presenting again and again, even though the correct anti-miasmatic simillimum is taken.I feel it could be the sheer vastness of symptons present within me that could be responsible for this.
Thank You.
I was expecting such a reply from the forum.When I started the treatment around 10 years ago, the remedies used to act for more than a week and would produce aggravations (mental and physical).But, with the sustained treatment over several years, I have reached a point where the specific selected remedy for the presenting miasm would complete its work in a few hours and I will feel better, but within the next couple of hours, the other miasm would present itself and it would need to be treated similarly.
My concern is why the miasms seem to be presenting again and again, even though the correct anti-miasmatic simillimum is taken.I feel it could be the sheer vastness of symptons present within me that could be responsible for this.
Thank You.
khanf last decade
I'm serious, a remedy can last weeks, months, or longer. One should never even fully judge the effect of a remedy as quickly as this, and I'm very skeptical of the person moving betwen 30 and 1M so strangely. For example, one day you've been given Lyc 30, and then 3 days later Lyc 1M. This is crazyness. I urge you to find someone who will treat your condition correctly.
♡ Homeopathy International 1 last decade
3 doses of remedy(e.g.Lyco 30) in 30 potency was prescribed.It brought slight/temporary relief.But, soon the same symptom picture will recur with much uneasiness.Repeating the same remedy in higher potency (1M) will remove the symptoms and I feel better....but, unfortunately the symptoms will again present themself, but with a different picture, different miasm ...:-(...that is my main problem..the remedies are prescribed correctly based upon symptoms totality, but the symptom picture changes quicky and the indicated remedy changes too...and a new prescription based upon the new symptom picture is needed....this happens again and again...countless no. of times...this is the sad reality I am facing....my feeling is that it is due to the sheer no. of symptoms that I have that there is NO REMEDY that covers the totality of my symptoms ACROSS the various miasms that I am born with/acquired..
khanf last decade
'a remedy can last weeks, months, or longer'...
in response to the above, I will say that it is true that a remedy can act for months or longer....BUT, only if the symptoms which are presenting themselves in the individual are COVERED within the symptom totality of that particular remedy....if the symptom picture deviates from that of the remedy...then a new remedy will be needed to cover the new total picture....this is my understanding of what seems to be happening in my case, where there is a very frequent need to change the remedies...
Thank You...
in response to the above, I will say that it is true that a remedy can act for months or longer....BUT, only if the symptoms which are presenting themselves in the individual are COVERED within the symptom totality of that particular remedy....if the symptom picture deviates from that of the remedy...then a new remedy will be needed to cover the new total picture....this is my understanding of what seems to be happening in my case, where there is a very frequent need to change the remedies...
Thank You...
khanf last decade
You are assessing the remedies before their action has even fully started. It can take months for a miasm to be removed before another miasm will express itself. Often if the remedy is correct, several miasms will dissolve at the same time. But you must let the correct remedy act for as long as it needs to.
If you are open to learning the correct methods, this forum can be a good place to learn.
At the very least, visit another homeopathy and see what they think of the method you've used.
If you are open to learning the correct methods, this forum can be a good place to learn.
At the very least, visit another homeopathy and see what they think of the method you've used.
♡ Homeopathy International 1 last decade
HI is correct, this is a terrible use of homoeopathic medicines. Despite your respect for the practitioner, he or she is making a mistake in changing remedies so quickly.
I have practiced homoeopathy for over 17 years now, I have never in all that time seen a patient *need* so many remedies prescribed in high potencies changed so quickly. Nor have I read of such a case in our literature. It is clear to anyone who understands homoeopathic philosophy that your homoeopath does not have a clue what to do for you.
In a chronic case, when the patient feels better initially, then worse, the remedy is *wrong* and the patient has merely experienced a palliation of their symptoms. If anything, it should happen the other way around - a worsening initially followed by improvement, which should last days, weeks and preferably months. Our guidelines are clear on what should happen, and it is not happening for you.
You are not being cured. Your homoeopath is acting desperately and irresponsibly. Find a new practioner as soon as possible. I cannot imagine what kind of mess this prescribing has created in your health. This is not Classical Homoeopathy - not by a long shot. This is the sort of homoeopathy that gives Classical Prescribers a bad name by masquerading under our banner.
David Kempson
Professional Homoeopath
I have practiced homoeopathy for over 17 years now, I have never in all that time seen a patient *need* so many remedies prescribed in high potencies changed so quickly. Nor have I read of such a case in our literature. It is clear to anyone who understands homoeopathic philosophy that your homoeopath does not have a clue what to do for you.
In a chronic case, when the patient feels better initially, then worse, the remedy is *wrong* and the patient has merely experienced a palliation of their symptoms. If anything, it should happen the other way around - a worsening initially followed by improvement, which should last days, weeks and preferably months. Our guidelines are clear on what should happen, and it is not happening for you.
You are not being cured. Your homoeopath is acting desperately and irresponsibly. Find a new practioner as soon as possible. I cannot imagine what kind of mess this prescribing has created in your health. This is not Classical Homoeopathy - not by a long shot. This is the sort of homoeopathy that gives Classical Prescribers a bad name by masquerading under our banner.
David Kempson
Professional Homoeopath
♡ brisbanehomoeopath last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.