The ABC Homeopathy Forum
Is Nat Mur ok for me ? Page 2 of 2
Page 1 2
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
for the skin rashes, you can take SULPHUR 200C now for some weeks.
take one dose every 3rd or 4th day.
when the skin rashes would subside, it would be helpful if you take PHOSPHORUS 200C some doses which i have always felt to be your constitution.
take one dose every 3rd or 4th day.
when the skin rashes would subside, it would be helpful if you take PHOSPHORUS 200C some doses which i have always felt to be your constitution.
♡ rishimba last decade
Dear Rishimba,
Thank you very much for the post.
Earlier when I had taken phosphorus, I had sever joint pains, weekness, rashes etc as reported earlier. Even after 20 days, it was continuing to produce sysmptoms, which led me to feel miserable rather than producing any improvements. Do you think it could have improved over time ?
After 3 days of stopping NAT MUR, I am feeling much better as far as the rashes are concerned. My appetite also is returning. I again have started feeling better in warm room. Mucus membrane of nose, which used to swell and block after collapsing on the polyp, does not swell now. Polyp size is also smaller.
But again sleepiness, dizziness, sudden loss of control and falling asleep around noon+-2 hours.
I remember you had said once that the effect of Phos has to be waited for upto 2 months. Do you think, it still might be working ?
Do you feel, I should wait for my natural condition to return before taking any medicine ?
Regards
SS Sankhla
Thank you very much for the post.
Earlier when I had taken phosphorus, I had sever joint pains, weekness, rashes etc as reported earlier. Even after 20 days, it was continuing to produce sysmptoms, which led me to feel miserable rather than producing any improvements. Do you think it could have improved over time ?
After 3 days of stopping NAT MUR, I am feeling much better as far as the rashes are concerned. My appetite also is returning. I again have started feeling better in warm room. Mucus membrane of nose, which used to swell and block after collapsing on the polyp, does not swell now. Polyp size is also smaller.
But again sleepiness, dizziness, sudden loss of control and falling asleep around noon+-2 hours.
I remember you had said once that the effect of Phos has to be waited for upto 2 months. Do you think, it still might be working ?
Do you feel, I should wait for my natural condition to return before taking any medicine ?
Regards
SS Sankhla
sssankhla last decade
please wait..and watch your improvements.
phos works for upto 60 days internally.
now, as you said you are feeling much better, you need to just continue your normal schedule of good food, adequate exercises etc. so that you get overall benifit from the remedies u have taken.
phos works for upto 60 days internally.
now, as you said you are feeling much better, you need to just continue your normal schedule of good food, adequate exercises etc. so that you get overall benifit from the remedies u have taken.
♡ rishimba last decade
Dear Rishimba,
I was going through the site of George Vithoukas, I found following para to be quite interesting,
'Frequently, particularly when there are mostly physical symptoms, Phosphorus may be difficult to differentiate from Natrum mur. Physically, both look quite similar - thin, sensitive, even perhaps hyperthyroid. The main point of differentiation, of course, is whether the patient has a personality which is closed or open. The sensitive person who tends to be more withheld and evasive, who leans back in the chair while describing symptoms, is more likely to need Natrum mur. The Phosphorus patient, on the other hand, is very open and expressive of emotion, tending to lean forward and engage the interviewer in personal contact.'
Was this the cause of the confusion ?
An interesting contradiction between the description above and my constitution is that I am not thin, but well built and stout (but average hieght). When young, used to physically dominate boys with bigger and taller bodies. Used to be arms wrestler in the hostel. My body is I think denser than most people I know.
I normally used to be single minded. Will do whatever (not like NUX-V), to achieve the goal, if convinced of the worth. This ZEAL is missing right now.
While I am not taking any medicine for the time being, I thought I will do some research. Any help from your side will be wellcome.
Regards
I was going through the site of George Vithoukas, I found following para to be quite interesting,
'Frequently, particularly when there are mostly physical symptoms, Phosphorus may be difficult to differentiate from Natrum mur. Physically, both look quite similar - thin, sensitive, even perhaps hyperthyroid. The main point of differentiation, of course, is whether the patient has a personality which is closed or open. The sensitive person who tends to be more withheld and evasive, who leans back in the chair while describing symptoms, is more likely to need Natrum mur. The Phosphorus patient, on the other hand, is very open and expressive of emotion, tending to lean forward and engage the interviewer in personal contact.'
Was this the cause of the confusion ?
An interesting contradiction between the description above and my constitution is that I am not thin, but well built and stout (but average hieght). When young, used to physically dominate boys with bigger and taller bodies. Used to be arms wrestler in the hostel. My body is I think denser than most people I know.
I normally used to be single minded. Will do whatever (not like NUX-V), to achieve the goal, if convinced of the worth. This ZEAL is missing right now.
While I am not taking any medicine for the time being, I thought I will do some research. Any help from your side will be wellcome.
Regards
sssankhla last decade
Dear Rishimba,
It has started raining in Delhi and the weather is little colder and air is wetter than what it used to be a week back. I have noticed that,
1. The nose has started blcoking again since yesterday due to inflammation of membrane.
2. Forced to blow nose. The discharge on blowing is watery and sometimes yellow.
3. Headache has returned.
4. The rashes have reduced.
5. Abdomen pain and flatulence obstructed is reduced significantly.
Headache and skin rashes seem to be alternating with each other. I am not so sure about the flatulence and pain in the abdomen, although this time as soon as the nose started blocking, the abdomen got better.
What is the suggestion ? I am not taking any medicine these days.
PS: BTW do you live in Delhi/NCR ?
Regards
SS Sankhla
It has started raining in Delhi and the weather is little colder and air is wetter than what it used to be a week back. I have noticed that,
1. The nose has started blcoking again since yesterday due to inflammation of membrane.
2. Forced to blow nose. The discharge on blowing is watery and sometimes yellow.
3. Headache has returned.
4. The rashes have reduced.
5. Abdomen pain and flatulence obstructed is reduced significantly.
Headache and skin rashes seem to be alternating with each other. I am not so sure about the flatulence and pain in the abdomen, although this time as soon as the nose started blocking, the abdomen got better.
What is the suggestion ? I am not taking any medicine these days.
PS: BTW do you live in Delhi/NCR ?
Regards
SS Sankhla
sssankhla last decade
Dear Rishimba,
Off late I do not see any posts from you on any case including mine. Have gone out or something ?
As I had written earlier, I was some learning for myself, to understand homeopathy better and perhaps to respond to it better. Somebody on the forum (Dr. Sajjad Akram I think), advised me to do grading and to point out unique symptoms.
Now this is what I did,
based on my physical symptoms, I shortlisted 5 top remedies, they were,
Sulphur,
Calcarea,
Phosphorus,
Puls and
Nat-M
Now since almost all of them had all the symptoms and that too in bold and italics.
I did further reading on repertorisation and grading and also went through the MM pages of Sulphur, Phos and Nat-M.
Based on whatever knowledge I gathered, I fed the mental and general Symptoms, at the WWW.HOMEOINT.COM (well found that software to be easier and more representative of Kent).
And you know what, you were right, the software threw the remedies in the following order,
Remedy Grades Points Occurances
Phosphorus 75 34
Pulsatila 61 29
Calcarea 63 28
Sulphur 61 27
Nat-Mur 57 26
NOW I KNOW YOU WERE RIGHT IN SELECTING THE REMEDY. YOU SELECTED THIS WITHOUT EVEN ASKING ME ABOUT PECULIAR SYMPTOMS. After going through the MM, I found that there is a particular symptom 'Delusion about floating in the air'
I sometimes get this dream.
Similarly, Anxiety is a big ruberic, but I also saw a subheading, 'Anxiety about others' (Mostly family and friends). There is another one 'SYMPATHETIC' as also 'AFFECTIONATE'.
Since the headace had come back, I took Phos-200 yesterday, as earlier. I suppose I have to wait now.
I will keep posting the progress (mainly headace, nose block and nasal polyps). Please keep guiding me and others who are need.
Thanks a lot for the support.
For your reference, I attaching two doc files, where I had repertorised my symptoms. Since the site allows only 20 symptoms per case, I put it into two (I have lots of symptoms, which confuse).
SS Sankhla Repertory Part-I
Sum of grades phos. puls. sulph. calc. nat-m.
Mind, restlessness, nervousness 1 3 3 3 2
Mind, reserved 1 2 * 2 1
Mind, prostration of mind 3 2 3 2 2
Mind, mildness 2 3 2 2 3
Mind, lasciviousness, lustful 3 2 * 2 1
Mind, irritability (See Anger) 3 3 3 3 3
Mind, indolence, aversion to
work 2 2 3 2 3
Mind, delusions, floating in air
(See Vertigo) 1 * * * *
Mind, delusions, imaginations,
hallucinations, illusions 2 2 3 2 *
Mind, courageous 1 1 1 * *
Mind, anxiety, others, for 2 * 2 * *
Mind, anxiety, health, about 2 1 1 2 *
Mind, anxiety, future, about 3 2 1 3 2
Mind, anxiety, fear, with 2 2 1 2 2
Mind, anxiety 3 3 3 3 2
Mind, anguish 2 1 * 3 *
Mind, abstraction of mind 3 * 2 * 2
Mind, absorbed, buried in
thought 1 2 3 1 2
Mind, absent-minded
(See Forgetful) 2 3 2 1 3
Mind, affectionate (See Love,
Indifference) 1 2 * * 2
SUM OF GRADES 40 36 33 33 30
OCCURENCES 20 17 15 15 14
SS Sankhla Repertory Part-II
Sum of grades phos. calc. sulph. sep. nat-m. lyc. puls.
Generalities, food, milk agg. 2 3 3 3 2 2 2
Generalities, cold, becoming
(agg.) 2 2 2 3 1 3 *
Generalities, cold in general agg. 3 3 2 3 2 3 2
Expectoration, white 3 2 2 3 3 3 2
Abdomen, flatulence, obstructed 2 2 2 1 2 2 3
Abdomen, fermentation
(See Rumbling) 2 1 1 * 2 3 *
Nose, polypus 2 3 2 2 * 1 1
Nose, inflammation 3 2 3 2 2 * 2
Head, pain, morning (agg.) 2 2 2 2 2 * 1
Vertigo 3 3 3 2 3 3 3
Mind, sympathetic 3 * * * 2 1 1
Mind, slowness 3 2 * 2 * * 2
Mind, sensitive, oversensitive
(See Offended) 3 2 3 2 3 3 3
Mind, sadness, mental
depression 2 3 3 3 3 3 3
SUM OF GRADES 35 30 28 28 27 27 25
OCCURENCES 14 13 12 12 12 11 12
Sort remedies according to Occurrences
Regards
Off late I do not see any posts from you on any case including mine. Have gone out or something ?
As I had written earlier, I was some learning for myself, to understand homeopathy better and perhaps to respond to it better. Somebody on the forum (Dr. Sajjad Akram I think), advised me to do grading and to point out unique symptoms.
Now this is what I did,
based on my physical symptoms, I shortlisted 5 top remedies, they were,
Sulphur,
Calcarea,
Phosphorus,
Puls and
Nat-M
Now since almost all of them had all the symptoms and that too in bold and italics.
I did further reading on repertorisation and grading and also went through the MM pages of Sulphur, Phos and Nat-M.
Based on whatever knowledge I gathered, I fed the mental and general Symptoms, at the WWW.HOMEOINT.COM (well found that software to be easier and more representative of Kent).
And you know what, you were right, the software threw the remedies in the following order,
Remedy Grades Points Occurances
Phosphorus 75 34
Pulsatila 61 29
Calcarea 63 28
Sulphur 61 27
Nat-Mur 57 26
NOW I KNOW YOU WERE RIGHT IN SELECTING THE REMEDY. YOU SELECTED THIS WITHOUT EVEN ASKING ME ABOUT PECULIAR SYMPTOMS. After going through the MM, I found that there is a particular symptom 'Delusion about floating in the air'
I sometimes get this dream.
Similarly, Anxiety is a big ruberic, but I also saw a subheading, 'Anxiety about others' (Mostly family and friends). There is another one 'SYMPATHETIC' as also 'AFFECTIONATE'.
Since the headace had come back, I took Phos-200 yesterday, as earlier. I suppose I have to wait now.
I will keep posting the progress (mainly headace, nose block and nasal polyps). Please keep guiding me and others who are need.
Thanks a lot for the support.
For your reference, I attaching two doc files, where I had repertorised my symptoms. Since the site allows only 20 symptoms per case, I put it into two (I have lots of symptoms, which confuse).
SS Sankhla Repertory Part-I
Sum of grades phos. puls. sulph. calc. nat-m.
Mind, restlessness, nervousness 1 3 3 3 2
Mind, reserved 1 2 * 2 1
Mind, prostration of mind 3 2 3 2 2
Mind, mildness 2 3 2 2 3
Mind, lasciviousness, lustful 3 2 * 2 1
Mind, irritability (See Anger) 3 3 3 3 3
Mind, indolence, aversion to
work 2 2 3 2 3
Mind, delusions, floating in air
(See Vertigo) 1 * * * *
Mind, delusions, imaginations,
hallucinations, illusions 2 2 3 2 *
Mind, courageous 1 1 1 * *
Mind, anxiety, others, for 2 * 2 * *
Mind, anxiety, health, about 2 1 1 2 *
Mind, anxiety, future, about 3 2 1 3 2
Mind, anxiety, fear, with 2 2 1 2 2
Mind, anxiety 3 3 3 3 2
Mind, anguish 2 1 * 3 *
Mind, abstraction of mind 3 * 2 * 2
Mind, absorbed, buried in
thought 1 2 3 1 2
Mind, absent-minded
(See Forgetful) 2 3 2 1 3
Mind, affectionate (See Love,
Indifference) 1 2 * * 2
SUM OF GRADES 40 36 33 33 30
OCCURENCES 20 17 15 15 14
SS Sankhla Repertory Part-II
Sum of grades phos. calc. sulph. sep. nat-m. lyc. puls.
Generalities, food, milk agg. 2 3 3 3 2 2 2
Generalities, cold, becoming
(agg.) 2 2 2 3 1 3 *
Generalities, cold in general agg. 3 3 2 3 2 3 2
Expectoration, white 3 2 2 3 3 3 2
Abdomen, flatulence, obstructed 2 2 2 1 2 2 3
Abdomen, fermentation
(See Rumbling) 2 1 1 * 2 3 *
Nose, polypus 2 3 2 2 * 1 1
Nose, inflammation 3 2 3 2 2 * 2
Head, pain, morning (agg.) 2 2 2 2 2 * 1
Vertigo 3 3 3 2 3 3 3
Mind, sympathetic 3 * * * 2 1 1
Mind, slowness 3 2 * 2 * * 2
Mind, sensitive, oversensitive
(See Offended) 3 2 3 2 3 3 3
Mind, sadness, mental
depression 2 3 3 3 3 3 3
SUM OF GRADES 35 30 28 28 27 27 25
OCCURENCES 14 13 12 12 12 11 12
Sort remedies according to Occurrences
Regards
sssankhla last decade
To post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register
Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.