psychotic problem _{Page 2 of 2}

I would love to take her case.I have treated two cases of similar type successfully.One of them is a very close relative and your wife's case reminds me so much of that case as the similarities are striking.

How does your wife react to a hot day?Does she have aversion to being in the sun or to sunlight on a hot day? Is she sensitive in her throat area?You can answer this if you recall whether she dislikes wearing anything which touches her throat. Does she like to wear loose clothes? You ask your wife to take out her tongue and see if it is difficult to put out the tongue too far?Dors the tongue tremble severely when outside the mouth?

Do you think your wife is a jealous person?Does she always accuse you of neglecting her and paying more attention to others?She keeps asking you do you love her or not?Is this issue of loving her a constant theme with her? Does she like to be physically caressed a lot when she is in a happy mood? Does she like the windows open or windows closed?Is she better in open air or in a closed room?What makes her worse cold or heat?Which weather she likes and which weather she doesn't like or symptoms are worse?Is she thirsty or has less thirst than normal?How about her digestion?Does it get disturbed by rich food?Is she a hardworking woman when normal or doesn't like to work?Her energy level.Is it low or high?Or is it so high that you can call her a hyperactive person?How does she sleep?On her abdomen or back or in knee chest position?

How does she respond to music?Does she like to dance or sing with the music or averse to it?Does she like the colors red,green,yellow and black or hate them or neutral with them?Is she afraid of the dark,ghosts, to be alone,lizards,spiders,snakes,dogs etc. or anything else.Is she talkative or a quiet person?Is she always competing with others or indifferent to people?Is she scared of shining objects such as a body of water or mirror etc.? Does she have a fascination for knives or any other fascination? Any particular dream or dreams that she repeatedly sees?Is she a very possessive person with respect to things/people she loves?
Also her menstrual cycle.Has it always been normal or some problems with it.Have you noticed what happens to her symptoms around the menstruation period.Do they become worse?

You can also mention other symptoms peculiar to her which you do not find usually in other people.

I have asked you so many questions.It is only to try and identify the right remedy as you have suffered so much.If you don't feel comfortable answering all these questions feel free to do so.But if you decide to give her case i promise to help you to the best of my ability and by God's grace we i.e. me and other homeopaths on this forum may be able to help her and you.

All the best.

Rajiv

Thankyou rajiv,

I will get back to you with all answers. Can I have you email address where I may send details more conveniently.

Regards

Lu.

Dear Lu,

My email id is rajivprasad underscore in at yahoo.com

Actually the entire mail id is continuous.But it is not possible to type it on this forum.So i have shown the different components of my mail id separately.I hope you understand.

The underscore is typed by pressing the 'hyphen' key keeping the 'shift' key pressed.

Rajiv

Dear Mr. Rajiv

Do u mean the underscore is between rajiv and prasad at yahoo or its rajivprasad_in at yohoo.

Regards

Lu

Dear Lu,

You have got it right.The underscore is as you have shown and not between 'rajiv' and 'prasad'. After the 'in' there is no space.The 'at' will come just next to 'in' without any space in between. then it is 'yahoo' and not 'yohoo' as you have mentioned.

Rajiv

Dear Mr. Rajiv,

Got iT! Thank you. You will receive an email soonest.

Regards

Lu.

Dear Mr. Rajiv,

An email with complete details was just sent to you.

Awaiting your reply .

Thanks and Regards

lu.

hi, I found this post through google and it's pretty much like my case, so I am resurrecting the thread and answering the extensive questionnaire posted by Mr. Rajik. his questions do throw light on my case, because I am a pathological example of many of the behaviors he is asking about - what medicine did he have in mind? I actually need help, but I am afraid of going to a psychiatrist, and think it will be somehwat useless because I am NOT going to take their medications which have lots of side effects. I've been diagnosed bipolar by a psychiatrist a year ago, i am a 29y/o female and self-diagnoed bipolar by age of 16



How does your wife react to a hot day?
I like it hot and wet, but not hot and dry. I like to go to the park and walk around if possible; the heat makes me feel blissful!

Does she have aversion to being in the sun or to sunlight on a hot day?
not at all! but falling asleep in the sun might make me wake up in a horrible mood, feeling like I need to take a shower and to eat something sweet.

Is she sensitive in her throat area?You can answer this if you recall whether she dislikes wearing anything which touches her throat.
I like to protect my throat from the cold, but I have a slight phobia of people touching the front of my neck. This phobia was very bad until ~3years ago, but it's getting less severe.

Does she like to wear loose clothes?
clothes MUST be loose otherwise I feel very tired, with my movements restricted.

You ask your wife to take out her tongue and see if it is difficult to put out the tongue too far?Dors the tongue tremble severely when outside the mouth?
no, and I can put it out like everyone else I guess

Do you think your wife is a jealous person?
YES. absolutely. everyone tells me i have some sort of existential jealousy, absolutely pathological, beyond anything they have ever seen.

Does she always accuse you of neglecting her and paying more attention to others?
EXACTLY. I always accuse my husband of that. That's exactly what made me start to act insane, and that's the most common trigger for my insane fits.


She keeps asking you do you love her or not?
YES. I also ask my husband if he loves me more than he loves his kid?, more than he loves his old shoes?, more than he loves a can of beans?, more than he loves god?, more than he loves elvis presley? etc


Is this issue of loving her a constant theme with her?
YEs, yes, yes. He does not help either, by threatening me with divorce at least three times a week, over roughly 3 years, and calling me all sorts of names. then he acts loving. anyway, the issue of loving me or not has always been an issue with my two ex-partners as well, and they did not try to scare me like my husband does.


Does she like to be physically caressed a lot when she is in a happy mood?
yes!

Does she like the windows open or windows closed?
open. i hate air-conditioning, it's a st*pid invention.


Is she better in open air or in a closed room?
put me in the house, I'll be in a rotten mood, put me outside, I'll feel like heaven, especially on the top of a mountain or on a grassy field.


What makes her worse cold or heat?
cold!

Which weather she likes and which weather she doesn't like or symptoms are worse?
i like it rainy and not cold. i like it moderately cold, like 15 celsius, and then i'll walk around with no sweatshirts, but colder than 10 celsius is bad, and i start wearing all sorts of protection against the cold, and try to stay inside. from 15 celsius to 40 celsius it's all good.


Is she thirsty or has less thirst than normal?
quite thirsty


How about her digestion?
horrible. maybe if i drink only juices for three days it starts to feel better.
i often spend the day with no food and eat only at night because once i eat my energy drops until i sleep and wake up again.


Does it get disturbed by rich food?
yes

Is she a hardworking woman when normal or doesn't like to work?
don't like to work. the responsibility and the fear of screwing things up make me really nervous. i like activity, but i am ver afraid of being judged bad, so i dont do anything and then i am only judged lazy, because people think i am very smart and very energetic too


Her energy level.Is it low or high?
varies a lot, i can be the most energetic person in the room, especially after a couple days of walking hours a day, my energy levels peak really high. but other days I feel lethargic and walk behind asking for whoever is with me to wait, please, wait.



Or is it so high that you can call her a hyperactive person?
yes, sometimes, i just have to dance and dance for hours, or walk uphill, do yoga, or simply walk around the house while stopping all the time to read a few pages or do half an hour of computer work which i need to do

How does she sleep?On her abdomen or back or in knee chest position?
either abdomen or knee chest, never on the back


How does she respond to music?Does she like to dance or sing with the music or averse to it?
i love it, but rarely when others are looking

Does she like the colors red, yes, a lot

green, i like green plants

yellow i do not make any effort to have yellow around me

and black most often i am dressed in black. sometimes black& red. more rarely black& blue

or hate them or neutral with them?Is she afraid of the dark, slightly, but i always sleep in the dark. i dont like being outside after sunset. i like being somewhere cozy after sunset.



ghosts, dont talk about ghosts or i'll start seeing them! it fr*aks me out a bit


to be alone, i like being alone


lizards, i dont care about lizards


spiders, i like to kill them, i sort of hate them


snakes, snakes, interesting. i am always the one who sees the snake in the woods. i have premonitory dreams about seeing snakes, and then there they are, a few days later. i feel them in my body (some sort of physical empathy). on the other hand, i try to stay away from them, so far i've succeeded well enough and neither me nor anyone in my company has been bitten. I fantasize about constricting snakes killing my husband's ex-wife, who made me very angry by trying to get back together with ihm after a year of them being divorced. i also fantasize about throuwing her in a pit of snakes.


dogs etc. i abolutely love dogs - whenever i see dogs i want to play with them.


or anything else. i have a special love for goats; i hate deer.


Is she talkative or a quiet person? in large social settings where people are talking bs, i lock and shut up, and wait for it to end very nervously. i am talkative if the subject interests me or maniacally talkative if i am having a fit of jealousy/rage


Is she always competing with others or indifferent to people?
i can become self-destructive in the course of competing so much. that's part of the reason why i isolate myself from other people, being free from the competitive instinct is quite a relief.


Is she scared of shining objects such as a body of water or mirror etc.?
i am fascinated by them

Does she have a fascination for knives yeah, i kinda like knives. i throw them on trees ,i play with them, people often tell me 'take care when cutting fruit/vegetables, look what youre doin' but i've never hurt myself like that except for the cases in which other people(father, husband are the one who become annoying about it) were harrassing me about it.

or any other fascination? Any particular dream or dreams that she repeatedly sees? crocodiles; beasts looking for me while i hide in a place that offers no prtection except for putting me out of sight (like a house with open windows, a room with an old door that does not lock and looks very fragile; water, animals. night. scary carnivals. being persecuted by people. large architectonic constructions, in different styles, futuristic, all marble, fort, giagntic church, etc


Is she a very possessive person with respect to things/people she loves?
a lot. people often comment on this.


Also her menstrual cycle.Has it always been normal or some problems with it.
i started taking vitex because i had such bad pms. i become much worse on pms, more angry, hiding more, more aggressive, more needy, crying, with a bloated belly, my breasts big hot and heavy, etc.

Have you noticed what happens to her symptoms around the menstruation period.Do they become worse?
yes yes yes


You can also mention other symptoms peculiar to her which you do not find usually in other people.
i think you have me covered on your previous questions, really. :)

Hi LU,

My wife has similar symptoms. Can you let me know the status now.

Dear Tip top
Homeopathic treatment is different from allopathic in that treatment is directed at the patient not the disease. The medicine that cured another case might be totally useless to you. If you want to have your wife treated you can open another thread answer the questions and invite opinions from interested persons. You will then have more options on starting treatment. By the way the questionnaire used was really very good .

Apart from that, this was a terrible example of case-taking. The prescriber/potential prescriber here asked direct questions trying to lead the poster to a specific remedy or set of remedies. This is a mistake in homoeopathy and usually results in failure.

A really terrible way to take a case. Nobody who gets any success in practice does this.

Dear evocationer
You are right of course. That aspect had escaped my attention. Thanks for pointing it out.

My comment was more for the poster than you Telescope - you seem to have a good grasp of homoeopathic philosophy :)