≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

Assessment of Prescribers on this forum

Hi everyone,

Since I have been following this forum for past few years, so I would like to share my observations regarding expertise' of prescribers on this forum. I would appreciate inputs from other people as well. But it will be good, if you people rate the prescribers based on their success rate instead of judging upon their nicer & friendlier behavior.

1- Dakter saab.... 9/10
2- Deoshlok.... 9/10
3- Maheeru.... 8/10
4- Anuj Shrivastava.... 8/10
5- Akshaymohl.... 8/10
6- Rashimba.... 7/10
7- Telescope.... 7/10
8- Parakletos.... 7/10
9- Dr David Kempson 7/10
10-Dr. Mefooz.... 7/10
11-Oantivirus....7/10

As i said, this is my personal opinion & you can disaggree with me. I hope no one will take it as personal attack or disgrace if I missed someone's name in the list
 
  AsadGhumman on 2015-07-24
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
thanks for this Assessment

Dr. Deoshlok Sharma
www.jdshospital.com
 
deoshlok 8 years ago
Asad,

Dr Saab is rarely on here, a few times
a year-takes 2 or 3 cases a year.
Deoshlok is rarely on here, does info posts, and does not do any follow up or
take a case.
Maheeru is doing maybe one case a year
Parakletos is not on here anymore
David Kempson is not on here anymore
Dr Mahfooz is not on here anymore.
Anuj is rarely on here anymore.

So this list is really not of any use as if people ask for these people they will most likely
get no response at all. Given that there are perhaps 150 new people
asking for help EACH month,I think it is wonderful that virtually
all of them are responded to by people who answer their many
questions, and can be relied on not to disappear, and also
give responses when asked, not forcing people to post and be reduced
to begging for an answer with people they trusted their health with. Advising-
I can't continue with you, find someone else, would be nice.
[message edited by simone717 on Fri, 24 Jul 2015 16:20:42 UTC]
 
simone717 8 years ago
Asad,

remember this is a forum and the moderator allows people
to prescribe- But it is set up as an info /discussion center
Not a clinic.

And please do the math-
you cannot compare people who cherry pick 4 cases a year with
people who are doing over 120 cases a year.
 
simone717 8 years ago
Well simone, I had already mentioned that this was my personal assessment regarding their knowledge & expertise & not about how friendly they are or how many cases they take in a year. I did not intend to dicuss personalities for their weaknesses. But in my view, what is the point in taking 120 cases when the cases have to linger on for years. The so called 120 cases takers keep on asking for a filled questionnaire when in most cases it is not required at all as the description given by the patient is enough to reach to the right remedy. Even when the given description is not enough, a few simple question can be sufficient. Questionnaire is required but very rarely. And funny enough, even after asking 10s of stupid questions, the remedies they prescribe are mostly wrong & the cases keep on lingering till on 20th-30th page of the thread, & if the patient is a lucky one, they reach to the right remedy after exhausting all other options. This simply is insult of homeopathy. Homeopathy is not a joke that you try 30 or 40 remedies one by one on a single patient who is seeking treatment of say kidney stones. Instead of dealing the cases like this, it is much better to ask the patient to seek help from someone else if they are not able to find suitable remedy in 2-3 weeks at most. Those who have the courage to accept their weakness are much more respectable I guess.

Lastly, since it was my personal assessment & in no way I am forcing my views down others' throats, so anybody could differ or disagree with me & post his/her own assessment regarding prescribers. BUT I expect others to respect my views reciprocally.
 
AsadGhumman 8 years ago
i agree with simone that is many prescribers do not follow the case and no one except me on this forum is making record list of cured cases which i think everyone should make, below is the link to it,

http://abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/471821/
 
0antivirus0 8 years ago
Asad,

I do not agree with regarding questions-Dr. Andre Saine, head of homeopaths in
Canada, and Jeremy Scherr famous teacher, and homeopath both
say that CASE taking is the most important aspect on how to zero in on
the best remedy for the patient at this moment in time.

They are very thorough, asking many, many questions.
Jeremey Scherr believes, that if you start thinking of a remedy at the
start you will go off track quickly. He advises to do a pre
analysis where you find out about vitality, sensitivity, pathology, real test
results, how many things are going on to be treated, what needs
to be treated first if necessary, ,then normal questions-and a final overview of asking
is there any problem with ... Each body part, so nothing is missed. Then come up with the
core of What needs to be cured in this patient- which you try to synthesize into a sentence-
and get the
rubrics for that. Finally, look at remedies, and he uses large rubrics , like
Boenninghausen, so he does not miss any small remedies


Cases with a lot of pathology he works with 12c instead of LM's
for a long time until there is aggravation and then goes from there.

Both these people have had incredible success in treating very complex
cases that homeopaths and Md's do not consider curable. They are master healers and their methods
make sense to me.


When people fill out a basic form, they don't tell enough, or they
leave many things out. Dr. Saab has said to me,What can you really do on
here because most of the info is "half-baked".

I guess you should do a thread showing how well you have healed people yourself with
minimum information . Lets see how you do. I am waiting for a thread to Say-
Hi, I am sick, give me something- and someone will tell them, Try this remedy.
You can't be right if tons of needed info is not in there - As in " I have thick mucous
for weeks" and then you find out later on , they have had it for YEARS along with other things
not mentioned.

People need to know they can investigate who they are working with, if they
click on peoples names and check out their past posts and success. If someone is taking remedy after remedy for months, and they are not improving,
They can thank that person, and make a thread for a New person If they want to. If you think the patient
needs to do that , then post on whatever thread and give the person OPTIONS. It is not against the rules.


120 cases vs 4 cases- the 120 cases could be very complicated, long term cases,
the 4 cases could be colds or flu or colic. Compare apples with apples.

-Remember, the forum is SET UP this way by the moderator so that ANYONE on Planet Earth can come
here and prescribe ANYTHING.(even if unsafe it is up to members to comment which I think
is dangerous as hardly anyone comments or interferes)

The forum has really nobody watching what is going on when the "general public"
wanders in here. It is a place where people can do "experiments" on unsuspecting people,
it is a place, where half the world thinks real drs. are on here bc nothing is done about
letting people call anyone a DR> for years and years, which gives an illusion of training and
experience, and it is a place where you can be harmed thru lack of knowledge , example:
one person telling a Mom to give her allergic to shellfish ( severe) son- give him some shrimp-
and then see if Nat Phos works. The child could have died- it happens to kids here all
the time on the bus if they eat some "nut" free cookie that has a trace of nuts in it. If
they don't have their Epi pen on them they often don't make it to the hospital.

Some things on here need to change, to be a better , safer place, but it is what it is.
All you can do if you don't like something is take the cases you can and do the best job
you can and post options for people if you disagree.The moderator has set up a Wild West scenario here, and that seems fine to him, the only safeguard
is other members comments.
[message edited by simone717 on Sun, 26 Jul 2015 14:45:43 UTC]
 
simone717 8 years ago
Hi Asad,

my english is not so good so please forgive me if I say something wrong. from my experience case study is must essential while taking a case but no one can say which one best

" a single remedy ""

" a bucket of remedy ""

you can search over intetnet 2 world famous doctor are here in india

one is BT rudresh ( the legend of classical homeopathy in india)

other is doctor prashsnt banarjee
people say him god here because he treats tumor and kensor( original spelling not allow here)

he give a at a time 7-10 remedy and he will exactly say how long he can save this pataient. 5 years, 7 years or 10 years


every month he attend lots of seminar world wide.

the doctor BT rudresh treats 100000 pataient till now officially with one remedy


but the core concept behind it is case study. it may be a 1 question or 100 question.

this thread saying assessment here.. how much will be for me out of 10 because in 15 days I treated 3 sex related problems patients and anxiety pataient.. now all are doing good. I show there are lots of cases almost tried 12 remedy for a errection problem not even one worked because the errection problem is a sensitive issue for man so they need more mental supports then remedy supports so case study and sweet words must essential.

we say here "" doctor take our pain by there sweet words "

so no one should be judge anyone's prescription here. just should be concentrate how to treat people.



couple of days somone member of forum just abused me lots and said many things but I was silent because I know he is sad and frustrated.. after that I proved myself by treating same type of case and now am sure he understands all..


so trust me I rate here my self 10/10.. but it's not a value. my aim is to learn here nothing else. so this assessment can't prove all..


I see one man nawaz khan he is doing great here. if somone tell how much u rate to nawaz? I can say more then everyone. so day by day people will come to study or try there experience to gain more experience. so we should not worry about assessment only we need to think
we all are here to help peoples for there best


good luck
 
sabkamalik1 8 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.