≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

a request to the forum moderator

It is my observation that these days there comes quite many posts on the forum which I call as "ONE LINERS".

There are many who just mention about their problem in one or two lines without giving any details of the symptoms.

I also find that many of such ONE LINERS go without any response for a long time due to obvious reasons.

This may just be happening because people do not know about how important are the symptoms for Homoeopathic prescriptions.

My request to moderators is that can there be some such a editing mechanism be devised in which the posting person gets the message that such brief posts will not get the due attention.
Through this post I also request all the on-going & new comers on the forum to kindly give as many details as possible about their problems & not just the name of the disease.

I would also request other homoeopaths on the forum to kindly post their response, comments & suggestions, in this regard.
Thank you all. Daktersaab

I also request all other on going
 
  daktersaab on 2015-06-27
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
Hi,

It is the moderator/owner Simon Broadley whose intention for
this forum is that it is a forum, not a clinic. It was set up to
be a discussion of homeopathy and anything else anyone wanted
to discuss.

That is why there is no standard intake form for peoples cases
( I have asked him similar things as you are stating)

Since it is not a "clinic" and at the top you see "posts are not from
medical professionals" then the moderator does not want
to give the impression that it is a "clinic".

At the start of the forum years ago, there were many discussions
between homeopaths about homeopathy, and also you could
see people who knew nothing trying to help other people who
knew nothing. There are no Western homeopaths
on here now,because "anyone" lets say a teenager, decided to join
and start prescribing- they can. Most Western homeopaths
decided this format was too unprofessional as they were juxtaposed between
doing work as they were trained, while the world public could
post on their thread and offer other bad, or dangerous advice,
such as rub Arnica on your head to get more hair.



So one day, a person is a patient, the next day he could be
giving a very wrong prescription to people- this happens frequently.

It is up to forum members then to police these things-and most
often they do not do that.

As far as one- liners, that is why people post their own form or
Rishimba's form- and some prescribers do give remedies based
off of no info. I have communicated how bad this is to the moderator
and he won't interfere with ANY prescription, all one can do
is post that it is a bad prescription and hope the person listens.
[message edited by simone717 on Sat, 27 Jun 2015 15:57:48 UTC]
 
simone717 8 years ago
NO body is going to pay attention to it even a warning is written on top to "give detailed information regarding ur health problem".People will going to read it same way as they are reading this one "Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis, and should not be used as a substitute for seeing a qualified homeopath or physician. In most cases, advice posted here is not given by a medical expert.
If symptoms persist, consult a medical professional."

It is upto the person who take a case to make sure the given information is enough or not.


People are just like"getting the free treatment why should we care" but every thing can not be cure on distance treatment there have to be certain test to do,Physically examination of disease even Physiologically examination is important for the mental patient.If u suggest some one this they will simply stop posting and make a new post .Even if u ask a questioner 20% people in this forum stop posting and make a new posts.


This forum is a great place for health support but it has its limit personally face to face contact is important for many diseases .THAT PEOPLE SHOULD UNDERSTAND
[message edited by gaintrox on Sat, 27 Jun 2015 16:02:16 UTC]
 
gaintrox 8 years ago
You are right Gaintrox.

Dr. Andre Saine, one of the worlds best homeopaths, thinks the number
one thing one has to do with any patient is EDUCATE them first.
Tell them what homeopathy is, what it can and cannot do, the importance
of a physical exam, the importance of their diet and lifestyle. He does all of that
first. Of course we cannot do the "physical" on here, but many people
with mental problems have them caused by an actual physical problem, so
if you do not get physically checked out, you can go down the wrong
path with remedies quickly.

However, since this is open to the world at large, it has been an education
for me to see how many people won't listen and have zero interest
in educating themselves. They just want medicine.
 
simone717 8 years ago
Hi simone and concern people,

before 3 months I came to know about abc homeopathy forum and just read some post and tried to understand the major logic behind it.. I thought it is like a chat room but later I understood it's a great mission to educate people and solve there problems..

couple of days back I did also a mistake by posting different post but simone explained me everything very well.. after that I understood what exactly he trying to say me

but it's not possible to watch everyone's post for him or anyone but I strongly agree homeopath should educate people first so we. pataient should understand that by describing our symptoms ""one line "" will not give any solution to us.. it's only faith on homeopathy and homeopat will give us benifit.


in india like me thousands of people didn't get any benifit by many homeopath.. so they all are frustrated and depress.. then they take help of Google or any discussion forum like abc homeopathy.


once they join, there thinking is like

may be I will fine..

let's try different homeopath..


I know it's wrong but honestly saying if you give a sharp look u will find many post from indian people crying for treatment Because they are not in a condition to understand what homeopathy Is.. "" the only reason behind is no one educate about homeopathy ""

I was doing also same.. but I.realised I have to pataince and keep faith on this forum but not blindly..

from all post I found there many doctors treated patients from india who all are failed by many treatment.

I will tell to everyone one thing "" this forum is not a homeopathy facebook "" it's a helping hand and ray of a new hope..

I don't know my problem or health issue will be solve or not but I really appreciate to owner of this forum that at least for people like me who is not able to take a treatment from a big homeopath in india because of all expensive treatment.. it's a ray of hope for them..

so if any pataient reading my post I will tell don't destroy your self by googling or self prescribing like me. just educate your self by saying "" I will be fine, homeopathy will heal me slowly " then try to reach good people here who can help you and make u to feel that u will be fine..

I am sorry if I said more but I want to help people by giving one message..


"" keep faith on homeopathy don't take it a chat room take it a ray of home for all broken people like me ""



stay blessed..
 
Brokenman1986 8 years ago
Dear broken man,

Nice post from you. I would prefer to start calling you Well Man,
hope you begin to set that phrase in your mind.

Many people have found good help on here as most people
on here are here to do volunteer work to serve the humanity.

Most that volunteer, do not like the fact that people can be
harmed on here, if they do not click prescriber name and
see who they are talking to- see how many posts the person
has done, get a feel for how they treat people etc.

When I first came on here, I myself thought it was a clinic. I thought
people WERE doctors who are not doctors. There are no MD's
on here. There are a few real homeopaths-
There is a cultural thing of India/Pakistan calling people who
help (Dr) but it confuses Western people, as they think it must
be a real title or no one would allow it.

More could be done instead of a tiny line, posts are not from
Medical Professionals- to let people know This is NOT a clinic,
but you can find helpful people on here.

I tell people everyday - this is not a clinic- otherwise it is kind
of a Sin of omission and gains strength the longer it goes on.
Why? because all these DR. Posts show up all over the internet
and if one is seeing Years of Dr. X or Y Repetition-it is hard to imagine that some
website would let this go on and on -some people who have been called Dr.
on here and have no health training at all have been the subject of discussion
on REAL Dr. forums- the REAL drs. are puzzled by what the fake Dr. is doing-
that is the danger of letting Dr. title go on and not letting people know
that Credentials are not checked on here at all.
- all the bad, harmful prescriptions
end up all over the internet too- Not a good thing.
[message edited by simone717 on Sat, 27 Jun 2015 23:04:28 UTC]
 
simone717 8 years ago

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.