≡ ▼
ABC Homeopathy Forum

 

The ABC Homeopathy Forum

jcs2006 (jacob scott)

has been banned for aggressive, intolerant posts and requesting contact away from the forum.

If anybody thinks a new member is JCS2006, please let me know.
 
  moderator on 2007-02-18
This is just a forum. Assume posts are not from medical professionals.
WOW, are you kidding?

Well at least yur not biased.
 
Ryelink last decade
Hi
Is this because of my post, i feel absolutely terrible if its because of my post to you
Elaine

p.s. I didn't mean any harm to anyone, i was just trying to clear up a matter from an e-mail i received that confused me from another homeopath is all, jacob has been really helpful to me
 
elainesmyth68 last decade
Dear Simon,

It is a bit confusing this time as regards the reason for Jacob's banning this time.If you think i was offended by any of his posts on the Indian Homeopathy thread then it is not so.He is a great friend of mine and i think he is an excellent homeopath and really wants to help the people.If people don't provoke him, he does not attack anyone.

But of course, moderator's judgement is final.

Rajiv
 
rajivprasad last decade
I'm sorry to see the banning. I think debate is healthy. I learned valuable info on the Indian homeopathy thread.
 
11:11 last decade
He was banned for asking for contact away from the forum, and for antagonistic posts.

I asked him to tone down his posts, as I have countless times in the past, and he responded thus:

'...I do not see I need to 'tone down my posts'.

...

As for the threat of being banned, this really isn't much of a threat at all, is it Simon, and we both know this. So wouldn't it be better to use your 'powers' of moderation in a more fair and nom threatening manner? I find this prevents people becoming annoyed at being spoken to as if they were children. '

(Full, unedited version at http://www.abchomeopathy.com/forum2.php/104464/ )

In order to keep the peace, I really don't see that there is another way of going forward, other than without Jacob.

Simon
 
moderator last decade
Moderator, are you Pankaj Varma
 
faqir last decade
As a new member on this forum, I feel the moderator has taken the right decision.

Jacob's tones were intimidating to say the least, especially for new members like me and the thread 'Indian homeopathy' was just to vent out his own ideas which sounded nothing more than pontification.

No one can refute the fact that this forum was much more productive without those endless debates about a miniscule strata of 'Indian homeopaths' who are not good enough according to Jacob.

Good job , moderator.
 
natasha_in last decade
Some time back , some Scientists came here arguing that homeopathy is nothing but water mixed with alcohol.They tried to argue that homeopathy is qauckery and all of those who believe in homeopathy is a bunch of fools.

During that time this self appointed protector of homeopathy was not to be seen around .Now suddenly he feels that Homeopathy is to be protected from the bad influence of Indian homeopaths and has started bashing indian homeopathy .
I dont think that there is such thing like indian homeopathy.
Bad homeopaths and good homeopaths are there through out the world. And since India happens to be one of the very few countries where english is spoken and is understood by many,it is quite natural that in many internet forums,presence of Indians are felt more.

George Vithoulkas speak about a great indian homeopath,
http://www.vithoulkas.com/EN/homeopathic_treatment_babies_children.html
David little talks about another great indian homeopath ,
http://www.hpathy.com/interviews/davidlittle1.asp
.
so it depends upon ones own mindset where you focus the spotlight. If somebody wants to highlight the negative aspects of a good system, it is upto him to do that and its upto others to ignore him.
Anil
 
Daniel Iype last decade
Yes, how dare that Jacob Scott, trying to promote classical homeopathy here on ABC. Please Jacob, no one wants to hear your crazy ideas of a single remedy at a time, or prescribing on totality of symptoms. What crazy ideas you put forth.lol.
 
Ryelink last decade
trying to promote classical homeopathy is a great thing to do and nobody objected to that
but telling that indian homeopaths are a threat to homeopathic science is a deplorable thing to do.
 
Daniel Iype last decade
Ryelink,

I agree with many of the points raised by Jacob, but what I don't agree with, and can't allow, is his contempt for other members, and the forum rules.

My job here is not to filter fact from fiction, or to promote a particular view, but simply to keep the forum approachable and friendly, and make sure the rules are upheld. Anybody whose posts are in accord with that aim is welcome, whether I agree with them or not.

Simon
 
moderator last decade

Post ReplyTo post a reply, you must first LOG ON or Register

 

Important
Information given in this forum is given by way of exchange of views only, and those views are not necessarily those of ABC Homeopathy. It is not to be treated as a medical diagnosis or prescription, and should not be used as a substitute for a consultation with a qualified homeopath or physician. It is possible that advice given here may be dangerous, and you should make your own checks that it is safe. If symptoms persist, seek professional medical attention. Bear in mind that even minor symptoms can be a sign of a more serious underlying condition, and a timely diagnosis by your doctor could save your life.